What Germans Know Could Help Bridge U.S. Workers' Skill Gap
Originally published on Sat March 8, 2014 11:31 am
Job training programs are failing to turn out enough skilled workers to fill job openings in the U.S., a phenomenon that puzzles some European companies that expand into the U.S.
President Obama freely admits that America needs to improve the way it trains workers. In a speech at a General Electric manufacturing plant in Wisconsin earlier this year, he said, "We gotta move away from what my labor secretary, Tom Perez, calls 'train and pray.' You train workers first and then you hope they get a job."
In other words, not enough Americans are training for the jobs industry needs to fill. Nationwide, about 4 million job openings are going unfilled, but 10 million people are unemployed, according to Labor Department statistics.
The phenomenon is puzzling to some European companies that have expanded to the U.S. and are used to a more skilled workforce.
The German Way To Train Workers
The White House has tapped Joe Biden to review America's jobs programs, a move welcomed by the German American Chamber of Commerce in Atlanta, which represents about 1,500 German companies throughout the South.
"It's pretty much that middle gap," explains spokeswoman Martina Stellmaszek. "They have no problems finding engineers — there are great engineers in the United States — or really very low-qualified jobs — there is also no problem filling that. But it's really that middle segment where in Germany, we have the vocational training system to exactly train for that."
Stellmazek is referring to the three-year apprenticeship every German trade worker must undergo before being certified in a skilled job. They work three or four days a week at a company and go to school for the other one or two days. The Chamber of Commerce awards the certificates and sets standards for what is taught in vocational schools.
"If you have a certificate that you're an electrician, it doesn't matter if you do it in Hamburg or Berlin," Stellmaszek says. "Companies know what they get."
Europeans are often baffled when they try to hire U.S. workers, she says.
"You don't really know what you get," she says. "If someone tells you they're an electrician, they could have just exchanged light bulbs at an amusement park or they could have worked, maybe, at complex problems."
Stellmazek knows it's impossible to import such an elaborate program to the U.S. It's based on the guild system of the 1800s, and counts on reciprocity — workers trained by a company must work their first three years for that company before they can leave. But the program is also the reason Germany isn't seeing a skills gap like the U.S.
College Educations Instead Of Manufacturing Skills
Emory University economist Raymond Hill says America's go-to-college message, boosted by college financial aid policies, worked in the U.S. for a while as manufacturing went offshore. But higher wages in China and a U.S. energy boom have changed the manufacturing landscape as well as the kind of jobs available. Now, companies can't find workers with the right training, Hill says.
"If you tell everybody, 'Get a college education; that gets you into the middle class. Doesn't matter what you major in, you just need that college degree.' Well, is it any surprise?" he says. "Now we see this manufacturing coming back to us, and that's what we have to get ourselves prepared for."
Hill is banking on a local approach to create a skilled workforce, in which companies partner more closely with tech schools. In Tennessee, for example, Volkswagen partnered with Chattanooga State Community College to import the first full three-year apprenticeship from Germany.
Later this year, the Obama administration will award one grant in each state to a community college with the most promising job training program.
SCOTT SIMON, HOST:
Yesterday, the U.S. Labor Department said employers added 175,000 jobs. That's more than economists had expected, but the U.S. unemployment rate is still high. Yet, many employers say they can't find the kind of employees they need, workers with specific skills. Economists say the U.S. has a skills gap. Companies just can't find workers who are ready to do the jobs that they need to be filled.
Now, the Obama administration says that something is wrong with America's job training program and it wants to find out how to fix it. From Atlanta, Susanna Capelouto reports.
SUSANNA CAPELOUTO, BYLINE: President Obama freely admits that America doesn't do a good job of training workers. Here he is speaking at a GE plant in Wisconsin earlier this year.
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: And we've got to move away from what my labor secretary Tom Perez calls train and pray. You know, you train workers first and then you hope they get a job.
CAPELOUTO: In other words, not enough Americans are training for the jobs industry needs. Just look at the job openings. There are about four million nationwide, but still ten million people are unemployed. That's according to government labor statistics. The White House has tapped Vice President Joe Biden to review America's jobs programs. That's a move welcomed by industry, including the German-American Chamber of Commerce in Atlanta. That's where Martina Stellmaszek works with about 1500 German companies throughout the south.
MARTINA STELLMASZEK: It's pretty much that middle gap, so they have no problems finding engineers. I mean, there are great engineers in the United States. Or really very low qualified jobs, there's also no problem filling that, but it's really that middle segment where in Germany we have the vocational training system to exactly train for that.
CAPELOUTO: Stellmaszek is talking about the three-year apprenticeship German workers must undergo before being certified in a skilled job. They work three or four days at a company and go to school for one or two days a week and it's the Chamber of Commerce which gives out the certificates and decides what's being taught in vo-tech schools.
STELLMASZEK: If you have a certificate that you're an electrician, it doesn't matter if you do it in Hamburg or in Berlin. Companies know what they get.
CAPELOUTO: And that, she says, trips up some Europeans hiring U.S. workers.
STELLMASZEK: You don't really know what you get. I mean, if someone tells you they are an electrician, they could have just exchanged light bulb at an amusement park, or they could have really worked maybe at complex problems.
CAPELOUTO: But Stellmaszek knows it's impossible to import such an elaborate program to the U.S. because it grew out of the old guild system of the 1800s and counts on reciprocity. Every company trains workers that can leave after three years, even to the competition. But it's also the reason Germany isn't seeing a skills gap like the U.S.
RAYMOND HILL: If you tell everybody get a college education that gets you into the middle class, doesn't matter what you major in, you know. You just need that college degree. Well, is it any surprise?
CAPELOUTO: Raymond Hill is an economist at Emory University. He says boosted by college financial aid policies that get-to-college message worked in the U.S. for a while as manufacturing went offshore and many factory jobs were lost. But now, higher wages in China and a U.S. energy boom are making a difference.
HILL: Now we see this manufacturing coming back to us and that's really what we have to get ourselves prepared for.
CAPELOUTO: Hill is banking on a local approach to create a skilled workforce where companies partner more closely with tech schools. Industry tailored job programs are a growing trend. For example, in Tennessee, Volkswagen partnered with Chattanooga's community college to import the first full three-year apprenticeship from Germany. Later this year, the Obama administration will award one grant in each state to a community college with the most promising job-training program.
For NRR News, I'm Susanna Capeluto in Atlanta.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
SIMON: And you're listening to NPR News.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC) Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.