Reuters Columnist Admits Error In News. Corp. Story

Originally published on July 14, 2011 7:51 am
Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit

: And he discussed his inaccurate findings yesterday in an interview with me on MORNING EDITION, so it our obligation to make a correction that is as prominent as the original mistake, you get the best information that we can get you, which is why we have invited David Cay Johnston back on to the same program. Mister Johnston, thanks for coming back.

DAVID CAY JOHNSTON: Well, thank you and for you policy.

: What happened?

CAY JOHNSTON: Well, News Corp. reported numbers as positive numbers for cash paid for taxes for three years and then switched to reporting them as negative numbers - that is numbers in parenthesis. And I didn't catch that those were negative numbers. And, you know, like when an airplane falls out of the sky, it's not one mechanical failure of a system, it's a whole escalading series of little things that they're wrong.

: Let's clarify for people. You...

CAY JOHNSTON: I spoke...

: Let's clarify for people. You were reading the financial disclosures that News Corp. has to make to the federal government, and you were confused about whether the - there were $4.8 billion - this a big number here - $4.8 billion over a number of years in taxes paid or whether they were actually tax refunds. That was the confusion here.

CAY JOHNSTON: That's exactly correct. And it turns out that the News Corporation makes inconsistent use, sometimes within the same table, of positive and negative numbers in its reports. Now News Corp. did disclose, on page 87 of its - the disclosure report for 2007, that it had made some changes. And let me read you the exact disclosure that they say points you to the fact that they went from positive numbers to negative numbers for the same thing. Certain fiscal 2006 and fiscal 2005 amounts have been reclassified to conform to the fiscal 2007 presentation.

: That was the clarification that you missed in the paperwork itself and so you were confused by the chart.

CAY JOHNSTON: Yeah. Even if I read it, and I don't recall if I read that line or not, I usually read the note that falls in, that would not have led me to think that they had switched the numbers from positive to negative. Now I also - by the way, there's no excuse for all of this. I am trying to explain it. I have always followed that practice. I did call the News Corp., spoke to two representatives, neither of whom so much as coughed when I said what I had found. And so...

: You're saying - wait a minute. You're saying you spoke with News Corp. before making this mistake, and they didn't correct you about the mistake?

CAY JOHNSTON: Absolutely. You know, I've never written a story in my life that anybody who is being criticized didn't know exactly what was coming.

: Although in the end, they said no comment. In a situation where the company is not helpful, did you have an extra...

CAY JOHNSTON: Well, they didn't comment. I didn't say they said no comment, they did not comment.

: In a situation where you don't get help from the company, did you have a greater obligation to try even harder to get the story right, really?

CAY JOHNSTON: But, yes, I was surprised that the company had - you know, they were just nonplused when I said this. Usually, when you have something, if it's off, in even a small detail, companies jump right on that. On the other hand, to be fair to them, remember, they're under siege right now from journalists from all these other issues facing Mr. Murdoch.

: Just to clarify the bottom line here. Rather than getting $4.8 billion over a number of years in tax refunds, News Corporation has paid $4.8 billion in taxes, by their accounting. And so they're paying quite a fair amount of taxes, aren't they?

CAY JOHNSTON: Absolutely. And that's exactly what the top of my new column says.

: You know, as word of these mistakes spread yesterday, I got a Twitter message from a man named Michael Arnold, who said that your initial claim was, quote, "obviously absurd." He suggested it should not have been made unchallenged by me. Was this an absurd idea that a giant corporation could get billions of dollars in refunds? We just got a few seconds left here.

CAY JOHNSTON: Oh no, not at all. Many companies run, for periods of years, negative taxes, and I have written about these and have documented them repeatedly, so that's not surprising at all. Companies also get to defer taxes. They get to reach back, unlike you and me, to the past and take losses today...

: Right. Right.

CAY JOHNSTON: ...offset profits.

: OK. Well, David Cay Johnston, thanks very much for coming back to apologize and to explain the mistake.

CAY JOHNSTON: Thank you, Steve.

: He's a columnist for Reuters. Now, before yesterday's interview, NPR did contact News Corp. for information about its taxes, didn't hear back. After the mistake, a News Corp. spokesman did write us to say they would have no comment. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.