NASA Says A Final Goodbye To Plucky Mars Rover

May 31, 2011
Originally published on June 1, 2011 11:21 am

NASA has pulled the plug on one of its two Mars rovers. Spirit hasn't been heard from in more than a year, and now the space agency says it's abandoning hope that it will hear from the rover again.

Any disappointment that Spirit's mission has come to an end has to be tempered by the fantastic success of the robotic explorer. Intended to last 90 days, Spirit operated in Gusev Crater on Mars for more than six Earth years.

Indeed, just landing safely on Mars has to be considered a success, since the red planet has a way of devouring space missions.

"When we landed, the view was spectacular, and everybody was very excited about the successful engineering achievement," says Jim Bell, now at Arizona State University. Bell was in charge of the main cameras on the rover. "What wasn't so clear is that there was a lot of scientific disappointment."

Disappointment because NASA sent Spirit to Mars to search for signs of water, and the rocks near the landing site were all made in a bone-dry environment.

The rover landed on Mars in January 2004, near some interesting-looking hills. "We could see them 3 kilometers off in the distance, and it was kind of a wistful feeling. It was, Wow, look at that, there's some really cool geology up there, but man, it's 3 km away, we're never going to get there, no way the rover is going to survive to go that far," says Bell. "Of course, none of us thought we'd be sitting on top of that peak in the not too distant future."

Bell says up in the hills, the science really started getting rich. There were plenty of rocks that were probably made when lava bubbling from under the ground mixed with water percolating through the ground. "One gets a mental picture of a Yellowstone-like environment on this part of Mars 3 billion years ago or more. And by our reckoning, on this planet, that's a habitable environment," says Bell.

The next Mars rover mission, scheduled for launch in November, will be looking for other places on Mars that might be even more hospitable to life.

'They Are Very Much Like Living Creatures'

Scientists and engineers frequently become attached to their projects. But rover mission manager John Callas says the rovers engendered a deeper connection.

"They see, they move, they interact, they respond to our commands, and they think on their own," says Callas. "And so they are very much like living creatures, and so we've become very fond of them. I know I've become very fond of the rovers."

"We're used to waking up each day and seeing the latest from the rovers," says former project scientist Albert Haldemann. "And they're always there, day in and day out. And if one day that stops being the case, it's going to be very sad."

Now that day has come. In anticipation of a fourth winter on Mars, engineers put Spirit in a kind of deep hibernation mode in March of last year, hoping it would wake up with spring. But it hasn't.

John Grant is a planetary scientist with the Smithsonian Institution. He has worked on rovers since well before they landed in 2004.

"I've had two kids since then. The oldest is about to go into kindergarten. So really, the rovers feel like a piece of the family," says Grant, and it's hard to let go. "There was a sense that they've overcome so much in the past, that we'd here from her again." When that didn't happen, Grant says, there was "I guess a sense of denial, but also a very deep sense of loss that we're not going to hear from Spirit again."

Spirit may be gone, but there's still one rover left. Its twin, Opportunity, is still chugging along on the other side of Mars, although scientists know one day it will go silent, too.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ROBERT SIEGEL, Host:

From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Robert Siegel.

MICHELE NORRIS, Host:

Now that NASA has declared the mission over, NPR's Joe Palca has this remembrance.

JOE PALCA: On landing day 2004, there was a powerful mix of anticipation and anxiety in the rover control room at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena. Everything was looking good. But space missions, especially missions to Mars, have a way of failing at the last minute. Lots can go wrong when you have to go from 10,000 miles per hour to a dead stop in six minutes. But everything worked.

JIM BELL: When we landed, the view was spectacular, and everybody was very excited about the successful engineering achievement.

PALCA: Jim Bell, now at Arizona State University, was in charge of the main cameras on the rover.

BELL: What wasn't so clear was that there was a lot of, sort of scientific disappointment.

PALCA: Disappointment because NASA sent Spirit to Mars to search for signs of water, and the rocks near the landing site were all made in a bone-dry environment. Not far from the landing site were some interesting looking hills.

BELL: We could see them three kilometers off in the distance, and it was just kind of a wistful feeling. It's like, wow, look at that. It looks like just some really cool geology up there. And - but, man, it's three kilometers away. We're never going to get there. There's no way the rover is going to survive to go that far. And of course, none of us ever imagined we'd be sitting on top of that peak in the distance - in the not too distant future.

PALCA: That's because the coffee table-sized rover far exceeded everyone's expectations. Bell says once in the hills, the science started getting exciting. There were signs that volcanic lava mixed with water to form an array of minerals.

BELL: One gets a sort of a mental picture of a Yellowstone-like environment on this part of Mars, you know, three billion years ago or more. And by our reckoning on this planet, that's a habitable environment.

PALCA: At first, it wasn't certain Spirit would even make it through the scheduled 90 days. This report was on ALL THINGS CONSIDERED just three weeks after landing.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED BROADCAST)

NORRIS: NASA's Mars rover Spirit is sick, and it may not fully recover.

PALCA: Two years later, ALL THINGS CONSIDERED reported on another danger looming for Spirit and its twin rover Opportunity.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED BROADCAST)

SIEGEL: Both are showing clear signs of age. And as NPR's Joe Palca reports, the extreme cold of a Martian winter could spell their doom.

PALCA: But both made it through that winter. Over the years, mission managers became very attached to the rovers. Mission manager John Callas shared these thoughts in 2006.

JOHN CALLAS: They see, they move, they interact, they respond to our commands, and they think on their own. And so they are very much like, you know, living creatures, and we've become very fond of them. I know I've become very fond of the rovers.

PALCA: For team members, the rovers became a fixture in their lives. Albert Haldemann was deputy mission scientist in 2006.

ALBERT HALDEMANN: We're used to waking up every day and seeing the latest from the rovers. And they're always there, every day, day in, day out. And if one day that stops being the case, it's going to be very sad.

PALCA: John Grant is a planetary scientist with the Smithsonian Institution and a member of the rover science team.

JOHN GRANT: There was a sense that they've overcome so much in the past that we'd hear from her again. And when that didn't happen, well, maybe this had happened, and they'll keep trying another way. And I guess, a sense of denial, but also a very deep sense of loss that we're not going to hear from Spirit again.

PALCA: Joe Palca, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.