Gustave Caillebotte: Impressions Of A Changing Paris

Jun 3, 2011
Originally published on June 6, 2011 3:51 pm

In the 1870s, an emperor and a baron undertook the remaking of Paris: Napoleon III and Baron Georges-Eugene Haussmann's urban renewal project converted clusters of medieval warrens into the Paris we know today, with its grand boulevards and rows of handsome buildings. Impressionist painters showed that new Paris on their canvases — but one of them had a very different perspective.

Gustave Caillebotte's best-known work, Paris Street: Rainy Day (above), painted in 1877, shows a vast cobblestone street, stretching out in front of looming, wedge-shaped buildings. The street is dotted with dark umbrellas that shelter top-hatted men, and women in long skirts — all looking vague and a little disoriented. That was a major subject of Caillebotte's: What the modernization of Paris was doing to its people.

"They seem to be quite alone," says Nicolas Sainte Fare Garnot, curator of the Jacquemart-Andre Museum. "Every person is lost in a very wide world."

The Jacquemart-Andre Museum, which is featuring an exhibition of Caillebotte's work, is located on Boulevard Haussmann — a broad and busy thoroughfare where, in the 1870s, wealthy Parisians built their mansions. (The museum was once the home of banker Edouard Andre and his wife, Nelie Jacquemart.) Caillebotte lived just down the street, and painted what was happening to Paris when Baron Haussmann was remaking it.

In Caillebotte's paintings, men leaning on new bridges seem engulfed by steel girders. Others stand on balconies, looking down at the Boulevard Haussmann — above, yet somehow dwarfed by, the street.

"Modern life doesn't create close relations between human beings," Garnot says. "You are [in] complete loneliness in these new buildings, new avenues, new boulevards. There's something quite sad about that."

Caillebotte's contemporaries — Renoir, Monet, Sisley, Pissaro — also put this "modern" Paris in their paintings. But theirs is a Paris peopled by happy dancers, or sociable boaters, or busy shoppers, or flag-waving parade marchers.

"They just wanted to show pleasant persons or fun activities," Garnot says, "not the kind of loneliness that you find [in Caillebotte.]"

It's Caillebotte's perspectives — his wide-angled, panoramic views — that shade the paintings with sadness. The zooming angles and thrusting spaces are daring, compelling, dramatic and totally original.

Not himself an Impressionist, Caillebotte loved what those painters and others were doing. He befriended them — Manet, Monet, Renoir, Sisley, Pissaro and Cezanne — at local cafes. Garnot says Manet had the habit of receiving friends at the Cafe Guerbois. Caillebotte decided to do the same thing — hosting the artists once a week.

Caillebotte didn't just wine and dine his artist friends — he loaned them money (in fact, he paid the rent on Monet's studio for a while.) And most importantly, he bought their paintings for top dollar. Caillebotte was very wealthy; his father had made a fortune supplying Napoleon's army with uniforms, bedding and other materials. Gustave inherited that fortune at age 26.

"He wanted to help the Impressionist painters," Garnot says. "So he purchased about 64 paintings from Monet, Renoir, Sisley, Pissaro and all the others."

One of the paintings in the Jacquemart-Andre show is a self-portrait Caillebotte made early in his painting life. He started painting relatively late, at age 27, and only lived to 45. In this 1879 self-portrait, he's 31 years old and seated at an easel in his apartment. Behind him on the wall hangs a painting that is now considered one of the greatest Impressionist works. It's Renoir's 1876 Dance at Le moulin de la Galette. Renoir shows a sun-dappled crowd of convivial partiers, dancing, drinking and schmoozing. Caillebotte was the first owner of this Renoir masterpiece, and reproduced it in his own self-portrait — as a salute.

He was a nervy painter, but not a professional one — and he didn't really have to be. Caillebotte had loads of money and didn't need to make his living from art. The 500 or so paintings he created stayed in his family. In part, that's why he's less well-known than his great painter pals. Caillebotte's pictures weren't in museum collections, and he didn't get serious attention until the 1960s.

But because he was a great patron of the arts, Caillebotte's first-rate art collection became what today is the crux of the Impressionist holdings at the Musee d'Orsay in Paris. Although for a while, he (or his executors) couldn't even give the paintings away. "It's a pity," Garnot says. "When he offered all [of] the collection to the French state, the minister of fine arts wasn't pleased at all by the donation. He refused it. He turned them away."

At the time, the custom was for the state to only accept works by dead painters. But that wasn't the only reason the paintings were rejected by the state: "You must understand," Garnot says, "that they didn't appreciate ... the style." Critics of the day felt the Impressionist works looked hasty, crude and unfinished. There was no place for them in prestigious, official French collections.

Caillebotte died in 1894. Seven years later, after much bickering, wrangling and negotiation, 40 of the 60 paintings in his bequest of Impressionist treasures were accepted by the government of France. Now, more than a century later, the names Renoir, Monet, Sisley — and, yes, Gustave Caillebotte — have become part of the Pantheon of French painting.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

RENEE MONTAGNE, Host:

But NPR special correspondent Susan Stamberg says one of them had a very different perspective.

(SOUNDBITE OF VEHICLES)

SUSAN STAMBERG: How do you say the name of the painter?

NICOLAS SAINTE FARE GARNOT: It's Gustave Caillebotte.

STAMBERG: Caillebut?

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: Caillebotte.

STAMBERG: Caillebut

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: Botte. Caillebotte.

STAMBERG: C-A-I-L-L-E-B-O-T-T-E, Caillebotte.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: Rainy Day", from 1877, is not in the exhibition. The Art Institute of Chicago owns it. Vast cobblestone street stretching out in front of wedges of buildings - pointy ends towards us. The street dotted with dark umbrellas that shelter men in top hats and long-skirted women, all looking vague, disoriented. That was a major subject of Caillebotte's - what the modernization of Paris was doing to its people.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: They seem to be quite alone.

STAMBERG: Nicolas Sainte Fare Garnot, curator of the Jacquemart-Andre Museum.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: Every person is lost in a very wide world.

STAMBERG: Caillebotte paints men leaning on new bridges, engulfed by steel girders. Men on balconies looking down at the Boulevard Haussmann above, yet somehow dwarfed by the street.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: The modern life doesn't create a close relation between human beings. You are completely lonely in these new buildings, new boulevards, new avenues and streets. And there is something quite sad about that, you know.

STAMBERG: Caillebotte's contemporaries - Renoir, Monet, Sisley, Pissarro - also put this modern Paris in their paintings. But theirs is a Paris peopled by happy dancers, or sociable boaters, or busy shoppers, or flag-waving parade marchers.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: They just wanted to show pleasant persons or funny activities. Not that kind of loneliness that you find here.

STAMBERG: Not himself an Impressionist, Caillebotte loved what those painters and others were doing and befriended them. Manet, first.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: And after you find Monet, Renoir, Sisley, Pissarro, Cezanne.

STAMBERG: He got to know them at cafes. Manet had the habit of receiving friends at the Cafe Guerbois. Caillebotte decided to do the same.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: He offered, you know, drinks and so on, once a week for everyone. And that's the way he met all these painters.

STAMBERG: If you wine them, they will come. Caillebotte not only wined them and dined them, he loaned them money; paid the rent on Monet's studio for a while. And most important, he bought their paintings for top dollar.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: Caillebotte was a very wealthy man.

STAMBERG: His father had made a fortune supplying Napoleon's army with uniforms, bedding, other materials. Gustave inherited the fortune at age 26.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: And he just wanted to help the Impressionist painters. So he purchased about 64 paintings from Monet, Renoir, Sisley, Pissarro and all the others.

STAMBERG: A great patron of the arts, Caillebotte's first-rate art collection became what today is the crux of the Impressionist holdings at the Musee d'Orsay in Paris; although for a while, he or his executors couldn't give them away.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: It's a pity in fact that when he offered all the collection to the French state, at that time the minister of fine arts wasn't pleased at all by the donation, and he refused it.

STAMBERG: He turned them away?

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: Yes.

STAMBERG: The custom then was for the state to accept only works by dead painters. But curator Sainte Fare Garno says there was another problem.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: But in fact, you must understand that they did not appreciate at all the style.

STAMBERG: Critics of the day felt the Impressionist works were crudely painted, looked unfinished, hasty. No place for them in prestigious, official French collections. Seven years after Caillebotte's death, after much wrangling and negotiation, his bequest of Impressionist treasures was accepted by the government of France.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: Well, at the end, he accepted about 40 paintings but the other were sent to the family.

STAMBERG: Forty out of 60 that were offered?

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: Yes.

STAMBERG: What was his name, this minister of fine arts?

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: Well, I'm afraid I don't remember it. I think its Anton de Proust. I'm not sure.

STAMBERG: This is a name that should live in infamy.

SAINTE FARE GARNOT: Sure. Sure.

STAMBERG: I'm Susan Stamberg, NPR News.

MARY LOUISE KELLY, Host:

And you can see some of Caillebotte's paintings at our website, NPR.org. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.