Facebook's Newest Challenger: Google Plus

Jun 29, 2011
Originally published on June 29, 2011 7:49 pm

Google is trying once again to challenge Facebook's domination of the social-networking business, this time with a service called Google Plus. But you're not allowed to join it — at least, not yet.

"It's small but growing," says Bradley Horowitz, who oversees Google's communications products and social applications.

Horowitz says Google Plus is still in "field-testing," so invitations have been sent only to a limited number of early adopters and journalists. It's similar to the roll-out strategy for Gmail and Google Voice. And if the company is lucky, the perceived scarcity will build up demand — but for what exactly?

"We've created a system that's based on the concept of circles, so that I can take my college friends and drag them into a circle called 'college buddies,' and I can take my work colleagues and drag them into a circle that's called 'work friends.' And I can share selectively the parts of myself with those circles that I choose to," he says.

In other words, Google Plus is trying to solve the age-old problem of what to do when you're friended by your mom. In a promotional video, Google promises that organizing your online life into circles may actually help you to loosen up.

Facebook allows users to do something similar, with an option called "groups." But some users complain the feature is clumsy to manage.

Google Plus, on the other hand, puts circles up front. Whenever you upload a photo or a bit of news, Google checks whom you intend to see it.

Richard Esguerra, of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, says the company seems to be trying to recover from privacy controversies involving its earlier social-networking efforts, like the ill-fated Google Buzz.

"They're trying to fix a lot of different things about their own approach to social networking and privacy," he says. "And also about the general social-networking model, and for now I think we're seeing a good start."

Google is also promising to let you move your information out of Google Plus, if you decide to, and the company says it will let you delete your information from its servers — a promise Facebook has never made.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ROBERT SIEGEL, Host:

From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Robert Siegel.

MELISSA BLOCK, Host:

Now, NPR's Martin Kaste reports Google is trying something else.

MARTIN KASTE: The new social network is called Google Plus, and you aren't allowed to join it - at least not yet.

BRADLEY HOROWITZ: It's small but growing.

KASTE: VP Bradley Horowitz says Google Plus is still in field testing, so invitations have been sent only to a limited number of early adopters and journalists. It's similar to the rollout strategy for Gmail and Google Voice. And if the company is lucky, the perceived scarcity will build up demand, but for what exactly?

HOROWITZ: We created a system that is based on the concept of circles so that I can take my college friends and drag them into a circle called college buddies, and I can take my work colleagues and drag them into a circle called work friends and share selectively the parts of myself with each of those circles that I choose to.

KASTE: Unidentified Woman: To bust out those dance moves (unintelligible) you definitely need to know.

(SOUNDBITE OF PROMOTIONAL VIDEO)

KASTE: Mr. RICHARD ESGUERRA (Senior Activist, Electronic Frontier Foundation) They're trying to fix a lot of different things, not about their own approach to social networking and privacy, but also, I think, about the general social networking model. And for now, I think, you know, we're seeing a good start.

KASTE: Martin Kaste, NPR News, Seattle. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.