Army Corps Makes Tough Calls With Floods

May 9, 2011

To handle all the water flowing down the Mississippi River, the Army Corps of Engineers is opening the floodgates on a spillway, north of New Orleans.

Opening the Bonnet Carre spillway diverts some of the floodwaters into Lake Pontchartrain and from there to the Gulf of Mexico. But nearly every flood control action taken by the Corps is not without controversy.

Winners And Losers

In almost every decision to divert floodwaters, there are winners and losers. With the opening of the Bonnet Carre spillway, John Lopez of the Lake Pontchartrain Basin Foundation says the loser will be the lake.

Within a few days, the brackish waters of the lake will be flushed out and replaced by nutrient-rich freshwater from the Mississippi. That will likely drive out the crabs and fish that normally call the lake home, and also promote algae blooms.

"The blooms can lead to low oxygen-anoxia or hypoxia in the lake," says Lopez. "There have been times when there has been some relatively minor fish kills."

Because of the danger and potential damage posed by the rising waters of the Mississippi, Lopez says his group doesn't oppose opening the spillway. It's a system, controlled by floodgates, that's been opened sporadically over the years.

Not a Decision Made Lightly

It's a much different situation than the floodway activated last week in southern Missouri. Over the course of four days, the Army Corps of Engineers blasted three openings in levees on the Birds Point floodway. It helped protect communities downstream and almost immediately reduced the level of the river by a couple of feet. But, in doing so, it flooded some 130,000 acres of farmland and forced evacuation of 100 homes.

Army Corps of Engineers Major General Michael Walsh said deciding to activate the floodway was not something he did lightly. At a news conference, he said, "I've known many of the people who have lived and worked in the floodway for the past three years. I consider them friends and certainly making the decision to put this in operation was a difficult decision."

One reason farmland near the Mississippi is so productive is precisely because it's received regular flooding from the river. Activating the floodway was part of a plan that's been part of the Mississippi's flood control design for more than 80 years.

But although it's long been in place, it's rarely been used. The last time was 74 years ago. At that time — as at this time — the decision was met with protests and lawsuits.

Charles Camillo is a historian with the Mississippi River Commission. He's studied transcripts of the congressional hearings after the historic 1927 Mississippi flood that led to the creation of the current flood control plan. Even then, there was opposition.

Camillo says, "It was best characterized by Congressman Dewey Short. He said, 'The people of Southeast Missouri do not want to become the dumping grounds to protect Cairo, Illinois, as much as we love Cairo, Illinois.'"

Craig Colten, a professor of geography at Louisiana State University, says that for the Army Corps of Engineers, controversy comes with the territory.

"Whenever you build structures to handle floods, you're walking that fine line between offering protection and failing to provide protection." The Corps, Colten says, "is going to be a lightning rod for any either failures, or even successes, that on a rare occasion cause damage."

Shadow of Katrina

For the Army Corps of Engineers, any criticism they're facing over how they're handling flooding on the Mississippi pales in comparison with the public scourging they received following Hurricane Katrina.

The Corps was targeted by many as the responsible party for the failure of New Orleans' levees — sharing the blame with local governments and contractors who performed sub-standard work.

In the nearly six years since, the Corps has done much to upgrade flood control — and its image — in New Orleans. Among the changes he sees in the Corps post-Katrina, Colten says it's careful now to downplay the level of protection provided by its flood control efforts.

"They're trying not to present their levees as infallible and as providing 100 percent protection," he says. "They perhaps exhibit a little less hubris than they did in the past."

As the Mississippi flooding moves downriver, the Army Corps of Engineers says some areas may even exceed levels seen in the historic 1927 flood. It's a reminder and a warning that even with the best flood control measures, living next to the river means sometimes getting wet. Copyright 2011 National Public Radio. To see more, visit